A child is, by definition, WRONG

Sen J senderellabrat at aol.com
Sun Dec 19 08:22:47 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 120087


> Meri:
**Sen Snipping**
In SS people criticize Harry for going after the Stone. But 
> remember, first he tried to go to Dumbledore and explain the 
> situation, and then he confessed everything to MM. But DD was gone 
> from the castle (as part of Quirell!Mort's plan) and MM *didn't 
> believe him*. He told her the truth and instead of taking him 
> seriously she dismissed him. And he was right: someone was trying 
to 
> steal the Stone and if Harry hadn't made it there when he did, 
there 
> is every possiblilty that Quirell!Mort would have figured out how 
to 
> get the Stone from the Mirror of Erised. 


Sen:

You make an excellent point Meri. How many times have we seen Harry 
actually *try* to go to an adult about something..anything... and 
*not* get shot down? These instances on top of the distrust the 
Dursleys' have ..beaten (for lack of a better word) into him would 
make anyone take matters into their own hands. If you strongly 
believe something and you've got the evidence (or even a series of 
suspicions that add up like in SS) and nobody else listens.. aren't 
you going to do something instead of sitting idly by?

Sen







More information about the HPforGrownups archive