Dumbledore In charge.

delwynmarch delwynmarch at yahoo.com
Sun Dec 19 22:59:25 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 120145


Alla wrote:
" I don't remember the quote, but I am almost positive that Dumbledore
says somewhere that he was sure that Voldie will return some day, so I
think he was making long time contingency plans. "

Del replies:
Wouldn't making long time contingency plans have included taking over
the Ministry and filling it with as many loyal followers as possible?
Imagine a Ministry where Shacklebolt is leading the Aurors and where
Arthur is directing a department, for a start. Not to mention no
Umbridge to send Dementors after Harry, of course. Wouldn't that have
been a much better situation to face the return of LV than the real
situation?

If anything, refusing the Ministry seems to have been a rather foolish
decision. Minerva, among others, would have been a good enough
Headmistress. DD would have been much more useful at the Ministry than
at Hogwarts. But I guess he chose Hogwarts because he wanted to be
there for Harry when the time would come.

Alla wrote :
"We don't know one way or another, but when did it ever stop us from 
speculating? :o)"

Del replies:
LOL !

Del







More information about the HPforGrownups archive