Umbridge and Hermione was Marrieta and ...

[pippin_999]

No: HPFGUIDX 120845


Eggplant:
> 
> I don't think definitions are very important in everyday
> life unless you're dealing in mathematics or formal logic,
> examples are far far more important, but if pressed I 
> suppose I'd say a good organization is one that does 
> mostly good and a evil organization is one that 
> does mostly evil. It works for me anyway.   
> 


Pippin:
Thanks for clarifying, Eggplant. Would you agree that the 
centaurs had become an evil organization by embracing racism, 
and that Hermione should have realized that?

She had a good half an hour, walking into the forest, to come up 
with a better plan, and I could come up with half a dozen better 
plans in that time...trip over a root and pretend to break my ankle, 
say that the weapon must have been moved to London and flee 
up the steps of Grimmauld Place when Umbridge took them 
there, Grawp, the merpeople, asking Harry to call Fawkes, Dobby 
(that one deserves all caps), -- there are a lot of creatures who 
would have helped Harry out of kindness or loyalty to 
Dumbledore. 

 What Hermione did, IMO, was the equivalent of trying to get the 
KKK to help her deal with a corrupt, evil, black person. It'd serve 
her right if they tried to lynch her too, and isn't that what 
happened? Don't worry about Hermione's comeuppance -- she 
got it already.

Pippin