Marietta and Hermione (was JKR's Messages ) (was Re: Hermione In Trouble?)

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 120888


Charme -
I understand what you're saying. However, Harry has horrors his 
schoolmates can't imagine, as Lupin eloquently tells Harry in PoA in 
response to Harry's concern he's weak because the Dementors affect 
him so.  Harry appears not to be mature enough to understand the 
importance of sharing such details; if he did, we might not have the 
story we do. :) Would the details of Cedric's death truly make an 
impact on those who have not experienced anything before 
or after LV's demise?


Alla:

Agreed. I don't think ANY details would have made those who did not 
believe Harry change his mind, only willingness to look in the face 
of the truth, OR the word of those whom general public respects.

And THAT'S what probably bugs me the most - I still think that 
general public OWED Harry to hear him out fully and THEN make up 
their mind whether to believe him or not.

Instead they chose to listen to corrupted journalists, controlled by 
Fudge. Oh, well, the truth alwasy comes to light eventually.

Just my opinion,

Alla