Re: book six and seven clichés

[suehpfan]

No: HPFGUIDX 91305


> > --- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "hermionekitten9" 
> > <kreneeb at h...> wrote:
> > > I saw this question on another web site, so I don't take any 
> credit 
> > > for it; I just thought that it was really interesting.
> > > 
> > > In the next upcoming books, what would be the most horrible, 
> mind 
> numbing, clichés that JKR could write? What would bring you to
> your knees, while you yell from pure joy? Things like Vampire 
> Snape, 
> sicky-sweet Draco, Harry getting some advise from Sirus via a 
> painting or a Spellotaped mirror, Harry/ Hermione, Ron/ Luna, 
> Neville goin' Matrix on Bellatrix, or Voldy. 
  Harry Potter Fans have been reading and then rereading these 
> books, 
> while dissecting every word. We have come up some interesting 
> theories that have been discussed as much as the books. We all 
> have 
> are favorites, and we all have are pet peeves. So... what's 
> yours?
> <lots of good stuff I agree with removed to save room>

Sue chimes in: 

 THE GOOD:

Harry is finally able to feel safe and the people he trusts are 
*really* trustworthy.

Lupin is cured, marries and lives happily ever after supporting 
himself and his 8 children writing children's books about magical 
creatures.

We get to see Dumbledore lounging on the beach.

Umbridge suffering anywhere.

Belatrix Lestrange gone.

THE BAD:

Harry devastated and unable to live a "normal" life.

Any Weasley a DE

Vampire!Snape

ESE! Lupin or Magonigal

Any Dursley with Magical Power

And I will add... THE UGLY

Umbridge in a postition of power anywhere

Lupin revealing himself as James and trying to defend his decision 
not to tell Harry in the first place.

Harry waking up in the cupboard under the stairs only to discover he 
has had a very long strange dream.