Sirius' Mirror

Tim tim at marvinhold.com
Fri Jan 2 19:59:36 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 87974

Tim wrote about Harry not using Sirius' mirror:
> I usually wave off JKR's inconsistancies due to the fact she is writing 
> a work for children. 

Carol:
> Harry *chose* not to use it or even open the package because he was
> afraid of endangering Sirius. 

Tim:
Now I must eat crow. 

I was not with my book when I penned the above responce to Athena.  
Since then I found the passage ( in the Occlumency (sp?) chapter I 
believe; once again at work without my books!)

In fact JKR foreshadows Black's Death in this passage as well as 
explaining why Harry so put it out of his mind. Not only did Harry 
put it in the bottom of his trunk, but Harry associated this action 
with protecting Sirius from Snape, not V. so the mirror did not come 
to mind when he was stressed by V. in the action leading to the climax.

Tim (blushing heavily and crawling under the desk)






More information about the HPforGrownups archive