Snape the spy
as_ziggy
as_ziggy at yahoo.com
Sun Jan 4 18:28:33 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 88073
Hello to all at HP fo rGrownups,
I just joined a few days ago and here I am venturing my first post.
I read a few fanfics in which Snape not only had spied for Dumbledore
but is still spying (up until Voldemort's defeat or other
circumstances where Snape's secret has to be exposed). I began to
wonder at the plausibility of it because I think there are a few
clues that Voldemort might have picked up on that Snape was loyal to
Dumbledore and not himself.
One clue occurs in the Philosopher's Stone. Wouldn't Voldemort have
suspected that Snape may have been loyal to the other side when Snape
was constantly going out of his way to stop Quirrel from getting the
stone? I'm sure it wouldn't have been difficult to notice from the
back of Quirrel's head. And even if he hadn't always hidden in
Quirrel's turban, Quirrel would have at least had to explain why he
hadn't gotten the stone yet.
Another clue would be that Snape did not attend the Death Eater
meeting in GoF when Voldemort returned and broke his followers out of
Azkaban. Missing such an important meeting, I imagine, would be a
huge offence and something that Voldemort noticed and should probably
be suspicious about.
In any case any suspicion on Voldemort's part should have made it
impossible for Snape to continue to spy for the Order. I think the
spying would have ended with Voldemort's first fall. If Snape did
any spying after that it would probably only be on the Death Eaters
who didn't get tossed in Azkaban and who still believed he was one of
them.
So now I'm wondering what you all think about Snape's spying career.
Speak out =)
Anna
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive