WHY a vampire? was No fire in the office

Julia jolka55 at poczta.onet.pl
Sun Jan 4 19:10:44 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 88077

Jazmyn :

> 1. Snape has not been witnessed drinking blood.
> 2. Snape has not been witnessed sleeping in a coffin, box of dirt or 
> anything like that.
> 3. Snape has not been witnessed during into a bat (or any other animals).
> 4. Snape has not been witnessed at any time with fangs.
> 5. Snape does not possess super human strength or he would have faired 
> better against being bounced off a wall and knocked out by a few kids 
> with wands.

Julia:

Yeah, you're right in that points but... If there were  canons for Snape drinking blood etc. , we 
wouldnt have been considering this topic. And btw this are obvious signs of being a vampire, 
and JKR just isn't obvious at any point, she likes mysteries.


> 6. Snape refereed a Quidditch game outside during the day and far as I 
> know, Sunblock won't stop the sun from destroying a vampire as its not 
> just UV rays that effect them.
> 7. Snape teaches classes during the daytime when all good little 
> blood-suckers are asleep.

He could be other type. There're vampires who don't die when they see the sun. Or he could 
be half-vampire (I'm supporter of this theory).

> 8. Vampires are not allowed to have wands as they are not 'humans' 
> anymore by definition as they cannot overcome their bloodthirsty natures 
> (despite what 'Buffy' fans think), unlike a Werewolf who can just lock 
> themselves up on a full moon.

But if he is a half-vampire he can have a wand (like Lupin). We cannot consider which Vampires 
or Werewolves are more dangerous because they both are (though in different ways...) 

> 9. Snape bleeds.  Undead don't bleed like humans.

Consider the possibility Snape is half-vampire

> 10. There is no canon to suggest anyone can be a half-vampire. Its like 
> being pregnant, you can't be 'a little bit pregnant'. You are either a 
> vampire or not a vampire. You can't say "I only suck blood on every 
> other Tues."  (Too many 'Vampire Hunter D' fans thinking Snape is like 
> 'D'.  Note that even D can't control his base nature all the time and 
> 'vamps out' when under a lot of stress or too close to a tasty neck. And 
> I don't consider Anime a good source of canon for a world whose magical 
> creatures so far have been based more on old legends, not new movies.)

I dont understand why you compare being a vampire to being pregnant... I dont have my 
sources in anime and movies. I read a few about Vampires. But remember that JKR creates her 
own world based on her imagination so there are some creatures which dont exists in real world 
(legends, myths)

> 11. Wearing black no more makes a person a vampire then wearing green 
> makes a person a leprechaun.
> 12. Living or working in a dungeon does not a vampire make. It might 
> make a grumpy, ill-tempered person who lacks a good tan though.
> 13. If everyone with black eyes was a vampire, then Hagrid would be one 
> too. Black eyes exist in real life, though it is linked with color 
> blindness.

These all things dont make you a vampire but I cant say that they cant be some clues. 

Julia who thinks that Snape is more likely to be half-vampire :D







More information about the HPforGrownups archive