GOF: US Murder vs UK Curse
Andrew
baseball_07_05 at yahoo.com
Mon Jan 5 03:00:51 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 88136
bboy_mn:
> From the US quoted text, I can not determine who will be murdered,
and why Voldemort thinks no one will notice.
>
> The usual suspects-
>
> -Bertha Jorkins (already dead)
> -Frank Bryce (soon to be dead <snip>)
> -Barty Crouch Jr (<snip> certainly he will live)
> -Barty Crouch Sr (but they didn't kill him, they kept him alive
> but at home <snip>)
> -the Real Mad-Eye Moody (well, they didn't kill him either. <snip>)
> -Dumbledore (Didn't see any early-on plot to kill or curse him)
> -Harry Potter (well, not Harry because his death comes at the end
> of the plan, not the beginning, and his death couldn't be a quiet
> unnoticed death)
On this, am I mistaken or was Crouch Sr. killed in the
Forbidden Forest and his body covered in the invisibility cloak.
That counts as a death. Although the UK edition does make more sense.
Andrew
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive