Vampire/Half Vampire/Schvampire -was all the other vampire Snape stuff
jakedjensen
jakejensen at hotmail.com
Wed Jan 14 04:21:09 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 88645
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "junediamanti" <
> June:
> No - I haven't. I hear what you are saying and I think you are
> quite unwilling to listen to MY points. I have yet to read a
> convincing rebuttal of the points I have made in answer to this
> theory and the various "clues" you say prove it. All I have read
is
> a constant re-iteration along the lines of "Vampire's can vary...
> there is more to Vampires than you know..." yada yada yada.
First, this is not really an accurate protrayal of previous posts. I
am not sure why, but you seem determined to be very angry at anyone
who even suggests that Snape might be a vampire. Let me be the first
to say that I understand you don't agree. That is cool with me. I
don't see why you get angry? It really takes all of the fun out of
this (I put up with enough angry people in my real life as a
teacher). I know you have a lot of passion in what you believe. I
know you make some good points. Just take a deep breath and make
your case. People will listen.
June:
Big question - still unanswered, why is it SO VERY necessary to you
> all for Snape to be a vampire? I prefer him human because I
believe
> he is a more interesting character as a flawed human being. So go
> on - what's your excuse?
Did you read the post I tossed up last night? It is just one example
of why it might matter. I am sure others have many different ideas.
It seems everyone has a different way the want the story to go and
how Snape's history (whatever it turns out to be) will fit in. In a
nutshell, something very significant had to happen to Snape to drive
him from LV and the DE and too DD. Does that mean he has to be a
vampire? No. I just think there is some fun canon support for it
and it is a stimulating idea to consider. If it turns out to be
wrong, oh well. A lot of theories on this board will (and already
have).
Jake
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive