Do the Dead Walk?

justcarol67 justcarol67 at yahoo.com
Tue Jan 20 04:18:54 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 89176

Tail end of a post by Koinonia02 in response to Anne:

> Anne
> > (Whose tempted to see if she can prove that Sirius will come back 
> as a vampire....yes folks. I AM crazy.....)
> 
> "K"
> Please try. 

Carol:
All the descriptions of Snape as pale and gaunt are echoed by
descriptions of Sirius (in his PoA incarnation) with exactly the same
traits (even bared and yellowish teeth). Yet much as Harry hates
Snape, it's Sirius, not Snape, whom Harry mentally compares with the
photos of vampires he's seen in his DADA books. And what about that
bottle of something that looks suspiciously like blood that turns up
durin the housecleaning at 12 Grimauld Place in OoP. Like most clues
in the HP books, it's there for a reason.

Carol, who doesn't think that either Snape or Sirius is a vampire, but
who thinks that if it must be one or the other, the evidence is
stronger for Sirius than for Snape

P.S. If there is a vampire in these books, it's most likely to be
Krum, who at least hails from the right part of Europe. C.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive