Perfume vs. Book

[confusinglyso]

No: HPFGUIDX 89346

>Helen wrote:
>Ah! But I think Hermione's gift to the boys is more telling.
>Hermione gave both boys identical gifts.

Now Phil, (confusinglyso)

The identical gifts were Homework Planners.

This post is really for Geoff Bannister and Shaun Hately.

In OoP (UK) Christmas on the Closed Ward page 443 the planner is
described as looking like a diary.
Neither boy is particularly impressed with the planners, indeed
IIRC Harry threatens to throw his away at some point.
I don't think either boy uses the planner much.
Hermione gave both the same gift yet neither boy ever noticed
the newsagents label inside.
Same newsagent as Tom Riddle diary,
but address now Wandsworth Road, London.

Just teasing   ;)

Phil(istine)