All the protections in Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone
pippin_999
foxmoth at qnet.com
Sun Jan 25 00:13:55 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 89573
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Fred Waldrop"
<fredwaldrop at y...> wrote:p here;
>
> Has anyone else thought that HRH were wrong about Sturgis
Podmore, and why he was sent to Azkaban for 6 months. (page
258 OotP UK) Maybe he was sent into the DoM to destroy the
Orb, but like DD, LV was watching also, and had his DE alert the
right people at the right time to stop Podmore.
> Until we find out more, we really do not know why Podmore
was trying to enter the DoM.
>
There is one clue which many have missed, including HRH
themselves. The surge of happiness Harry felt when he was in
Umbridge's office coincided with Podmore's sentencing. This
argues very strongly that Sturgis was loyal to Dumbledore.
Podmore cannot have been framed by the Ministry, since they
would have let the Prophet know if they'd suspected he was one
of Dumbledore's people. Therefore, he must have been set up
by Voldemort . Of course all this happens *before* Kreacher
defected, proving there is indeed a traitor in the Order.
Moody says, on page 182 US that Podmore had failed to show
up for the second time in a week. I think the first failure was
because he had been captured by LV's forces, put under
Imperius and commanded to steal the Orb, just as Bode was.
I have thought of another reason Dumbledore couldn't break in to
the Department of Mysteries to destroy the Orb. He could not
have broken through the protections undetected. Harry's dreams
do not take him past the doorway because, until Rookwood's
escape, Voldemort himself did not know how to get through.
Pippin
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive