Animagi Lupin? Re: Marauder's Map: Selective Against Marauders? Somewhat OT question.

[trisana_farwell]

No: HPFGUIDX 103967

> Pandrea wrote:
> > Do we know that the Map can see through an animagi disguise?  
<snip>
 
> Fx wrote:
> In PoA Lupin says he was studying the map when he saw "three 
> people going under the tree".  He says there was Ron, Sirius 
> and Peter.  We know that Sirius and Peter were in their animal
> form and only Ron was normal shaped.  This would suggest that 
> the map indeed sees through animagi.  


Trisana asks:

This just raised another question in my mind.  Is Lupin a true 
animagi?  We all know he's a werewolf, but can he really transform 
into his form on demand like the other Marauders?

I suppose since they all learned the skill, Lupin could be an 
animagi, but that doesn't seem logical at the same time, since he 
naturally transforms every month anyway (like a woman on her period, 
I say *giggles*).

Ah, and because it -is- my first post here:  Hi!  I'm Trisana, and I 
suspect that this isn't really the best place for my HP obsession, 
since it seems to fuel it even more. :P  I've been hanging around the 
fandom since I was eleven (I'm now seventeen) so that makes, wowzers, 
about five years!  (Sorry, that's the first time this year I've 
calculated how many years I've been here.)  I decided to join HP4GU 
to try something new, as far as communities go.  It seems like every 
corner of the fandom is different. :P  Anyway, I'm excited to see such 
well supported theories flying around here.

~Trisana