Goyle was not at MOM and is not in Azkaban

potioncat willsonkmom at msn.com
Sun Jul 4 17:06:29 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 104285

 
> Samnanya
> Harry might indeed know if he was listening carefully at the door 
to 
> Lucius Malfoy barking out orders for the death eaters to split 
into 
> groups. THere were 12 de's there and if you check the names, Goyle 
was 
> not among them. JKR spent a lot of words describing who went 
where, 
> and Goyle was noticeable in his absence {so was wormtail, but that 
> wasnt quite as glaring to me. Goyle and Crabbe are always 
describled 
> together - like sons like fathers]
> Goyle would not need to go on the lam because he did not "commit a 
> crime". Last i recall, it is not a crime to assemble in a 
cemetary, 
> even if you are welcoming the return of the dark lord. And it has 
been 
> established that trials are necessary in the WW needed to prove 
guilt 
> or innocence.

Potioncat:
How many of the 12 were named?  (Sorry, I don't know the answer.)  I 
also thought (think) Goyle wasn't there because as you say he wasn't 
named and usually we think of Crabbe and Goyle together.  But we 
don't really know if he was there. 

So, if he was there, he is in Azkaban.  It doesn't appear that 
anyone escaped.  If he wasn't there, he has at least been cast in a 
bad light and will need to be careful, now that the MoM will be 
rounding up suspicious characters.
Potioncat





More information about the HPforGrownups archive