SHIP: Harry and Hermione Foreshadowing in PoA movie?

[grace701]

No: HPFGUIDX 104354

mayeaux45 wrote:
> Could it be that Harry and Hermione will end up together before 
the 
> end of the series?  JKR has already gone on record in an interview 
> in late May saying that 'the hairs on the back of her neck were 
> standing on end'  She actually got chills watching the movie!  She 
> couldn't believe that Alfonso had predicted as many things as he 
> did.  Which leads me to the main question...Harry and Hermione? 
> 
> First of all Alfonso decides for a close up shot on Hermione 
> whenever Harry comes down stairs to greet them while staying at 
the 
> Leaky Cauldron.  Second, Alfonso so cleverly puts an homage to Y 
tu 
> Mama Tambien in the movie by having the three young stars console 
> each other at the execution of Buckbeak.  Note: Harry is consoling 
> Hermione and Hermione is holding on to Ron, but who is Ron 
> consoling...?  No one!  Before I go on, let me just add that there 
> are some clues to Ron and Hermione as well, but we're focusing on 
> Harry and Hermione at this particular time.  
> 
> Moving on... The third clue is when Alfonso has Hermione fall onto 
> Harry when entering the Whomping Willow tree (that's not in the 
> books)!  Clue Four, Harry and Hermione are holding each other's 
hands 
> at many points in the movie (even at times when it is not needed...
> Ex: going up the stairs to the Shrieking Shack, running through 
the 
> forests, and so on)!!!!  
> 
> Clue Five, the music that was chosen for each scene is amazing.  
> Alfonso is known for his attention to detail.  When Harry and 
> Hermione were sitting down waiting for 'themselves' to come out of 
> the whomping willow, the imagery and music that was playing was 
> really "magical" (almost romantic?) The camera pans from the birds 
> that were flying from the sky towards Harry and Hermione sitting 
> under the tree.  Clue Six, Hindsight is 20/20...think about that! 
> (The Time Turner)...draw your own conclusions about this one.  
Clue 
> Seven, the position in which Harry and Hermione were sitting 
> underneath the tree.  Hermione was sitting slightly behind Harry.  
> The way in which she looked at him was foreshadowing all on its 
own.
> 
> NOTE: I'm also a fan of Ron/Hermione, so I'm not really biased 
with 
> the whole Harry/Hermione relationship!  Just wanted all you R/Hr 
> fans out there to know that.  But you have to admit...the clues 
are 
> there (in the movie and especially after OotP).  Let me know what 
> you think!  


Just for the record, I am a fan of H/Hr and I see the foreshadowing 
of which you mention.  I'm not quite sure if it's foreshadowing a 
possible relationship in HBP or book 7, but in the meantime it does 
indeed foreshadow their relationship in OoP.  For example, Harry 
protecting Hermione in movie!PoA is not canon for book!PoA, but for 
OoP.  Hand-holding has not been shown in any of the books, if I 
remember correctly; perhaps for the upcoming books.  What Cuarón did 
in PoA is what JKR has been doing since PoA: subtlety showing us a 
developing relationship from friends to something more.  

Grace, who is half asleep so if she did not make any sense please 
forgive her