24 hours (was Re: About Prophesies and Protections)

[a_silmariel]

No: HPFGUIDX 104384

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Amey Chinchorkar"
<sherlockholme_ac at r...> wrote:

>>>Carolina :
> 
>>>Look in the PS/DVD. There's an interview with Rowling where she
talks about that scene. At least in the spanish edition. 
>>>That's why I consider those few seconds canon (or very close to)
and I find interesting the 'You heard James?' line combined with James
specifically not appearing in the scene.
 
> - Amey:
> A really good observation, and that casts a different light on the
scene. But in GoF, Harry hears his father saying your mother is
coming, then he might wonder if this was not the voice he heard. It is
possible that he is a bit preoccupied then in fight than the voice,
but still its a theory. (Though this part is removed from GoF now, so
the whole theory might be wrong :))

I'm not saying James wasn't there. I can hardly assume anything that
night. Only that the fact he does not appear in the 'camera (not
harry's) pov' is quite interesting, because that means something we
must not see was going on camera.
 
What happened? I don't know, but I expect the author to oversmart us,
not to write a 'it was nothing, after all' scene. Something is rotten
 in James' death.

Carolina