HBP and COS

[Casey]

No: HPFGUIDX 104387

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "jakedjensen" 
<jakejensen at h...> wrote:
> Almost a year ago there was a thread focused on what scene JKR 
told 
> S. Kloves (screenwriter for HP movies) not to cut from COS because 
it 
> was important for the series. Now there is all this talk about the 
> HBP and, primarily, who the HBP might be. Is it possible that the 
> scene in COS where S. Finnegan reveals his background (i.e., that 
he 
> is a half blood) is the scene JKR saved from the cutting room 
floor? 

Wasn't Seamus' parental revelation in PS/SS? He said his "Mam was a 
with and his father was a Muggle." I don't remember a CoS discussion 
about this.

I'm not saying it isn't him, just that the revelation was in the 
first book.

Casey