HBP and COS

[jakedjensen]

No: HPFGUIDX 104626

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Casey" <caseylane at w...> wrote:
> Wasn't Seamus' parental revelation in PS/SS? He said his "Mam was a 
> with and his father was a Muggle." I don't remember a CoS 
discussion 
> about this.
> 
> I'm not saying it isn't him, just that the revelation was in the 
> first book.
> 
> Casey

Casey, you are correct. Seamus did reveal his lineage both in book 
one and movie one. Curses! Just when I thought this cut scene thing 
was starting to make sense.

The only thing salvaging this idea is if Jo Rowling was just talking 
about conversations she had had with Kloves in general about writing 
the screenplays (the conversation does not suggest this, in fact, it 
suggests they are talking about CoS). However, it is possible. 

So, that said, is there anyone out there with an idea of what scene 
Jo might have insisted stay in (not to understand the movie, but as 
clues for the book) now that we know all about this half blood prince 
stuff?

Jake

PS. Who still says the HBP is Seamus Finnegan, Godric Griffindor, or 
Tom Riddle.