McGonagall's character was Re: Sirius revisited

[aggiepaddy]

No: HPFGUIDX 104444

Kneasy wrote:
> > 
> > The canon I've been waiting for someone to post? The backing for
> > McGonagall's statement that would make me withdraw?
> > It's in PoA chap 18. 
> > Look it up.

Potioncat:
> Clever!  Too clever, Sir!  We must all hang our heads in shame and 
> admit that you have twice over duped us! You have sent us to the 
> very site that supports your original statement!
> 
> So I concur,  McGonagall is not to be trusted.


I'm sorry but I can no longer lurk, I must interject!! I do apologise 
if I have missed something (as I have only recently discovered this 
fantastic web site) but WHAT??  I have noted with my lurking that 
Kneasy seems to rule as intellectual king, but for him/her to send us 
off on a double-cross just to 'prove' his theory doesn't seem to ring 
true.  I may be being naive here but I take that passage in PoA to be 
a fitting account of how it is.  Becoming an animagi MUST be 
difficult, otherwise surely nearly every wizard would be one!! 

Just my POV.  Hi and I hope that my first post is acceptable. 

While I'm here, can someone please explain who Mark Evans is???  
Please forgive my ignorance!!

Aggie