McGonagall's character was Re: Sirius revisited

[potioncat]

No: HPFGUIDX 104460

Aggie wrote: 
 I have noted with my lurking that Kneasy seems to rule as 
intellectual king, but for him/her to send us 
> off on a double-cross just to 'prove' his theory doesn't seem to 
ring 
> true.  

Potioncat to List Elves:
Quick, delete that last line before Kneasy reads it!  That's all we 
need!

Aggie:
I may be being naive here but I take that passage in PoA to be 
> a fitting account of how it is.  Becoming an animagi MUST be 
> difficult, otherwise surely nearly every wizard would be one!!

Potioncat: 
Yes, the passage, which has been snipped away now, did indeed 
support the idea that Serius, although not a serious student, most 
likely had stellar grades.

It was just my way of getting back at Kneasy.  (Once you get to know 
us, you'll know who's kidding and when and who is never kidding!  
Just wait till you hear about the Snape twins)
 
Aggie: 
> While I'm here, can someone please explain who Mark Evans is???  
> Please forgive my ignorance!!


Mark Evans is mentioned very briefly in one of the first chapters.  
He's a 10 year old who has been beaten up byDudley.  The important 
part (we think) is that his last name is Evans just like Harry's 
Mum. 

Very good first post and welcome to Bedlam!

Potioncat