CoS versus the Dark Mark (was Re: Sirius,Snape,Lily,CoS)

Adan adanabbett at yahoo.com
Tue Jul 6 01:02:39 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 104559

> Snow:
> What if only the Tom Riddle portion of Voldemort was transferred 
> to Harry that night at Godric's Hollow? <snip> Harry isn't tied 
> to Voldemort just to Tom Riddle who is in turn connected with 
> Voldemort. <snip> So it is like three separate entities that are
> all connected. Therefore there may very well be three people 
> involved in the prophecy: Harry, Tom and Voldemort. 
>
> "
And either (Harry or Tom) must die at the hand of the other 
> (Voldemort) for neither (Harry or Tom) can live while the other 
> (Voldemort) survives
"


Adan here, somewhat confused:
Okay, I think y'all are saying that, basically, there is a bit of Tom 
in both Harry and Voldemort.  That that is their connection.  And I 
can see that.  Really, I can.  I just don't see how it is to be 
either Harry or Tom that must die.  Would killing Tom in one, 
automatically kill him in the other?  And then, if Tom is what is 
keeping Voldemort alive, then that would kill Voldemort? I'm so 
confused.  






More information about the HPforGrownups archive