Dumbledore to be trusted?

paul_terzis paul_terzis at yahoo.gr
Thu Jul 8 05:28:41 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 104983

>
> Maren Gest Wrote:
> Has anyone else noticed that Dumbledore seems to never be around 
when somethings happening with Harry and Voldemort (The first book 
he was called away on importaint duties, the second the govenors 
sent him away, and the fourth he wasn't there for the graveyeard 
part) The 5th book is the only one with Voldemort in it that 
Dumbledore was there to help, but it wasn't until he very end did he 
intervine. I think its possible that Dumbledore is not really as 
good as we think he is. Also how is it possible for Dumbledore not 
to catch that Pro. Moody in book four is not the real Moody? Even in 
the Penisive Dumbledore seems to be some what friends with the old 
man, and they have known each other for a long time. Mr.Weasley even 
says Dumbledore never miss' a trick, so how is it possible that he 
wasn't able to tell a good friend was an imposter, Fake Moody 
couldn't have been that good of an imposter?!
> 
> 

My friend you are right. Something is wrong with DD in general. I am 
sure that he is hiding a lot more than that he divulged to HP at the 
end of OOTP. I had said in a previous post of mine that there many 
people with their own agenda in the Potterverse. Everyone is using 
HP as his/her puppet. One of the them is surely DD. The problem is 
that we don't know what his agenda includes. If I were HP I wouldn't 
trust DD so easily.

Cheers,
Paul





More information about the HPforGrownups archive