Neville and other questions

kandbmom kandbmom at yahoo.com
Thu Jul 8 16:25:19 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 105085

I have been reading all the posts and have a few theories on some of 
them.  
       Neville and Snape- What if Snape was the other person to hear 
the prophecy with Dumbledore?  He would know that Neville could have 
been the one to kill LV.
       Snape- I also believe that he is playing both sides either for 
the good of the Order or tricking Dumbledore.  I think that in the 
GOF that Snape was "the next man" standing next to the space that 
should have be filled by the LaStranges.  JKR doesn't say who this 
man is but does make him important by pointing him out.  I think 
Snape also was one one the DEs performing muggle torture at the 
Quidditch Cup.  He was torture the same way by James with his robes 
over his head and his grey undies showing.
     Death of the Potters- I believe that LV was not alone when he 
killed the Potters.  JKR never tells who all is with him.  He is 
always accompanied by DE so it would be good to assume that he is 
here also.  I think the LeStranges were there and some that we don't 
know are DE yet.  One theory is Rita Skeeter- she called Hermione 
a "Silly Girl" in GOF and that is what Harry hears being said to his 
Mother.  It is never said that LV said "Stand Aside, Silly Girl" only 
that Harry hears it being said.
 
     Only theories I would enjoy any comments!
            kandbmom 






More information about the HPforGrownups archive