Who's the third dead death eater???

[Jen Reese]

No: HPFGUIDX 105663

Neri:

> Checking something in the graveyard scene (GoF, Ch. 33) I just 
came across something I've missed before: The largest gap in the DEs 
> circle includes 3 empty places, where LV says should have stood 
three DEs who are "dead in my service". OK, I know two of the DEs he 
> means: Rosier and Wilkes. But who's the third? Am I missing 
someone obvious? He can't be meaning Regulus Black, right?An 
> unaccounted DE is a very suspicious thing, even (or especially) if 
> he's supposed to be dead.


Jen: I wouldn't put it past Voldemort to say Regulus died in his 
service, lol. Here are some other possibilities:

1) Quirrell. Might be a possibility, but it sounds like the meeting 
in Albania was purely coincidental; LV didn't know him prior to 
that. 

2) Florence. You gave me the idea for this one Neri, from your 
excellent post on the Slytherin gang.

3) Mrs. Crouch! Highly unlikley, but we have no information on her 
and she DID help her son escape.

4) Mystery person. Someone in the Order photo who was actually a 
spy, besides Wormtail. We have the Prewett brothers, Dorcas Meadows, 
Edgar Bones, Benjy Fenwick & Marlene McKinnon. The only one with 
connections we know of are the Prewett brothers with Molly.

Something to think about. I might just have to vote for Mrs. Crouch 
on this one!

Jen, wondering if Mrs. Crouch is important because she did sacrifice 
herslef for her son like someone else we know....