Out On A Limb About Florence

[aggiepaddy]

No: HPFGUIDX 106018

> Gina: 
> has anyone thought maybe that was snape and lily? I have no
> doubt in my mind that the hexer was Snape but maybe the girl was 
Lily <snip>



Aggie;
I'm not sure about it being Snape and Lily but you did make me think 
of something that I don't think has been mentioned before.

Most of the posters seem to be assuming that because it was Bertha 
that saw the kiss and got hexed, that Flo and the boy were in her 
year at school.  Could it not be possible that they were in a couple 
years below her?  She followed him (why was she following him?) but 
he wasn't in her year.  Perhaps she had a crush on him (but that 
doesn't really add weight to the theory as most girls fancy boys the 
same age or older. At least at school they do).   Perhaps she knew 
that he was into the dark arts (lends weight to boy=Snape), but then 
why would she tease him? I wouldn't want to tease Snape!!! Although 
13 yr old Snape would be less intimidating than 36 yr old Snape.  

Hmmm maybe I'm talking myself round to your way of thinking 
Gina!!! ;o)