[HPforGrownups] Re: Out On A Limb About Florence

[Miller, Gina (JIS)]

No: HPFGUIDX 106020

*         Aggie;
I'm not sure about it being Snape and Lily but you did make me think of
something that I don't think has been mentioned before.
 
Hmmm maybe I'm talking myself round to your way of thinking 
Gina!!! ;o)   


Gina: 
*               LOL! That may be a scary thing! :-) Sirius did not speak all
that fondly of her either did he? Maybe it was him and the girl from the
pensieve staring at the back of his head. Or Maybe the girl in love with
Sirius WAS Bertha and she followed him only to see him kiss someone else..
Oh the possibilities! Maybe it was Lupin kissing Lily and he hexed her so
that James would not find out. I still lean towards Snape because DD sounded
sort of exasperated to me like she should have know she was going to get
hexed. DD would have realized how fragile Snapes temper was and thus wanted
to keep people from bothering him.
            Gina - who adores this list and all discussions about the future
books!


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]