Dobby redux

[Paula Gaon]

No: HPFGUIDX 106214

14July04
 
Kneasy wrote:

"Personally I can't stand the little creep (Dobby).
It may be movie contamination but the expression on his face when 
levitating the cake in CoS just confirmed my prejudices.
A sly, vicious leer...."
 
Paula:
I see what you mean.  I'm way behind on the movies, have only see CoS so far, and felt very disappointed at the portrayal of Dobby.  I had imagined him completely different--more cuddly and sympatico"

Kneasy:
"Dobby is under orders from Lucius.
After all, it's not just a single visit to Privet Drive we're talking 
about, he drops in on Harry at Hogwarts a few times too. How often can 
House Elves flout their masters wishes, for Heavens sake? Once - 
possible; more seems a bit iffy  to me."
 
Paula:
I really bristled when I read this.  Didn't Dobby give Harry the Gillyweed at the last minute to dive into the lake in GoF?  But then it occurred to me, wait a minute, of course Lucius would want Harry to survive this task to meet old Voldy in the cemetery.  Kneasy, maybe you're on to something...
 
Paula Gaon




See Something REALLY Special at--new updates:

https://www.cafeshops.com/bft/216705

See the Magical Creatures at:

http://www.cafeshops.com/bft/311142
















		
---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Mail - 50x more storage than other providers!

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]