Sirius Luring Snape

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 106666


Alla previously
> > I was trying to figure out why Snape followed Marauders int he 
> first  place? I refuse to think that his initial motivations were to
> get 
> > them in trouble.
> > 
> > I want to think he wanted to be liked and accepted by them and 
> was  not. Maybe Remus knew that Sirius /or James and Snape 
> were somehow  related (cousins, I don't know)
> > 
>

Pippin: 
> But everyone with pureblood  ancestry is related, though they 
> may not be willing to associate with one another. Sirius says 
> Snape and James hated each other from the moment they first 
> set eyes on each other and that James was every thing Snape 
> wanted to be. There could be some thwarted hero worship 
> underneath it all.
> 
> I have the idea  that Snape might have  polyjuiced himself into 
> James at some point, and that Sirius found out about it but 
> couldn't prove it without getting the real James into trouble too 
> (since he was somewhere he wasn't supposed to be at the 
> time.)



Alla:

Yes, I know that everyone is distantly related, but I am thinking 
more about direct relatives. There was something that Harry did not 
pay attention to on that tapestry, right? Another surprise for us?


Hmmm, Snape polyjuicing himself? Could be, could be.

I want to hear more. Do you think he tried to court Lily disguised as 
James?


Pippin:
 
> BTW, I don't think we can prove anything by what got left out of a 
> movie. Septology clues can get moved around--JKR did it herself 
> by moving the half blood prince from Book Two to Book Six.  
> Backstory can be filled in at any time.
> 


Alla:

No, I don't think we can prove a lot from the movie. but it is all 
JKR's fault. Why did she mention that foreshadowing? :o)
Anyways, Snape's shielding the trio cured me from ESE!Snape for now.

As for Lupin, well it is just metathinking, but as I said before he 
looked at Harry with so much love and pain in his eyes, that I cannot 
imagine him to be evil anymore. I just can't