Sirius Luring Snape

[pippin_999]

No: HPFGUIDX 106745

 
> Alla:
> 
> Yes, I know that everyone is distantly related, but I am thinking 
 more about direct relatives. There was something that Harry did 
not  pay attention to on that tapestry, right? Another surprise for 
us?<

Pippin:
Could be.  I just don't think that a major plot point is going to 
hinge on long lost relatives. Too Star Wars.

Alla:
> Hmmm, Snape polyjuicing himself? Could be, could be.
> 
> I want to hear more. Do you think he tried to court Lily 
disguised as  James?<

Pippin:
I've thought of that...trouble is, the chronology doesn't fit. If the 
prank happened in sixth year, then James hadn't started going 
out with Lily yet. On the other hand maybe that's the point. It 
would be very funny and a typical JKR twist if Snape-as-James 
was somehow responsible for Lily's change of heart. Maybe...

 
> Alla:

> As for Lupin, well it is just metathinking, but as I said before he 
 looked at Harry with so much love and pain in his eyes, that I 
cannot  imagine him to be evil anymore. I just can't<

We know  he's capable of murder. That much of ESE!Lupin is 
canon. He was going to kill Pettigrew...and you don't think he had 
it in him to try to kill Snape? ::shrugs::

Pippin