Life debt, Lavender, Draco and Fawkes

[Amey Chinchorkar]

No: HPFGUIDX 106739

-	Kneasy    
-	As for Ginny, Dudders, etc. No, Harry was busy saving his own life
-	at the time; their survival was incidental to and a consequence of his 
-	own survival.

Amey:
Not for Ginny, he went willingly to the CoS to save her. It was his decision to go there. As for Dudders, yes, it was saving both the skins at the same time. And I don't think Dudders is bright enough to nitice Harry saved him.


-	Ginger:  
-	Lavender has been seen as a Muggleborn by some listees as she didn't 
-	know what the Grim was.  I say that sounds reasonable.  

Amey:
Also, one more thing, she has (er.. had) a rabbit as her pet. Seems so mugglish
 doesn’t it? I mean they are not even mentioned on the school list, and nobody has them as pets im Hogwarts.

-	Demetra
-	An unimportant side note, but I wondered why the heck Sirius never 
-	bought Lupin a new set of dang robes?  Sirius obviously has the 
-	money.  I suppose it could be a pride thing with Lupin (like Ron), 
-	but Harry managed to procure a new set of dress robes for his 
-	friend.  Why couldnt Sirius?  

Amey:
Harry arranged *Gred and Forge* to give the robes to Ron, who would give it to Lupin? Nymphadora maybe?

-	Alla:
-	I argued earlier that I find the condemnation of every eleven year 
-	old who comes to Slytherin to be very silly, because children cannot 
-	be evil at eleven.

Amey:
What would you call young Draco at age 11? Ok, we are using the word evil very freely here, but to say it politely, he comes up as a stuck-up young boy who needs a bit of cane every day to keep him on ground. (Sorry, can't help it)

-	[Lee]:
-	Possible...very possible. And, also possible, that Fawkes will be a constant
-	fixture at Hogwarts, moving from Headmaster to Headmaster, which would
-	preclude Harry getting him.

Amey:
Imagine Fawkes serving Phinus Nigellus!!!! Help!!! 
I don’t think he is passed from Headmaster to Headmaster, Dumbledore got him as a pet from somewhere or somebody (maybe Godric as may people say here). Dumbledore seems as the natural successor. Phoenixes live many years and so, it might be there from founder’s time as well.

Amey




[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]