Time Travel by Harry and Black Family Tree

[Amey Chinchorkar]

No: HPFGUIDX 106743

-	Alla:
-	Jen, if Harry inded goes back in time as it was speculated could be 
-	it be that he goes back to the Founders Time and talks to Salasar and 
-	Godric and finds out what truly happened between them and how the 
-	rift can be healed back in our days?
-	I don't know, I like that, but I think it is more likely that Harry 
-	will go to GH, if he were to go at all.
-	Maybe he will make couple of stops on his journey?
-	Maybe Harry will ask Salasar whether Voldemort is true heir? (I know, 
-	it is quite an outlandish speculation)

Amey:
I doubt Dumbledore will allow Harry to go into past to change anything in the past which is of such a great importance. I mean dissolving the rift between GG and SS will mean that there is no CoS, no basilisk, and at the very least, that removes at least 1 death and at least 4-5 near deaths (I mean, we don’t know when CoS was opened before TR opened it, so we don’t have exact figures, but I think somehow there are very few deaths, as even 1 death was enough to put the school on threshold of shutting down in TR’s time). So that makes a really huge change in the time fabric. 
Also, going to GH, I doubt Harry will be able to help his parents. If he does and that is where LV is vanquished, his parents are not dead, he has no scar (hell, did I just predict the end of part 7? People, you heard it here first. Hogwarts, here I come as next Divination teacher). 
All in all, I doubt Harry will change any deaths, if he goes at all, it will be just going to watch and learn, not do anything.

-	Neri
-	Having Narcissa in Slytherin in the same or similar year as young 
-	Severus might lead to some interesting dynamics, especially as Lucius 
-	was not there, and in light of the present day relations between 
-	Snape and Lucius. I leave this to your wild imagination, as we're 
-	already late in this lengthy post.

Amey:
A really great analysis! I have one point which might solve the discrepancy. We are told nowhere that all BAN were born to same parents. They are all cousins of Sirius, but they may have different parents. Personally I think, Narcissa is same age or 1-2 years older than Marauders (and Lily) as their children are same age group. Andromeda is at least 3-4 years older, given Nymphadora’s age, and Bellatrix is around Lucius’s age, 1-2 years younger. That makes IMO, Narcissa and Andromeda as borm of same parents and Bella as their cousin. 

Amey, who is hoping at least Andromeda inherits 12,GP



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]