New JKR FAQ Poll: Which is significant?

Liz Muir rowen_lm at yahoo.com
Tue Jul 20 02:20:57 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 106979

> Stefanie ponders:
> Looking at JKR's new FAQ poll on her website, and looking as what 
> canon has to offer us, which option do you think would help us the 
> most? I haven't given it too much thought, yet, but as of right 
now, 
> I'm absolutely stumped as to which I'm going to vote for...

As I see it, there are three factors that should go into deciding 
which FAQ to vote for:
1) Will JKR even give us an answer?  She's notorious for "Sorry, 
can't tell you" answers.  Though it being in a FAQ means she's more 
likely to give us something.
2) How useful is this info going to be?  With the Mark Evans 
question, that info could have been key to a lot of theories, 
whereas the other two weren't so much.  This question could also be 
worded as, "How much are you dying to know?"
3) How key will this info be to the plot?  Similar to the 2nd 
question: is this really going to matter?  Also related to the 1st 
question, because the more central it is to the plot, the less 
likely it is that she'll tell us.  :D

So here's my rankings, on a scale of 1-5, 5 being good, 3 being 
maybe and 1 being bad:
> //1) Is Percy working undercover for any secret 
organization/boss?//

1) 5
2) 4
3) 2

> //2) Where has Peter Pettigrew (Wormtail) been since the end 
of 'Goblet of Fire'?//

1) 3
2) 4
3) 5

> //3) What did Dumbledore's Howler to Aunt Petunia mean? ('Remember 
> my last'?)//

1) 3
2) 5
3) 5

So . . . they're all about even, but I think I'll vote for #3.  What 
do you think?

Rowen





More information about the HPforGrownups archive