[HPforGrownups] Re: New JKR FAQ Poll: Which is significant?

[Shannon]

No: HPFGUIDX 107030


>Rowen says:
>
>As I see it, there are three factors that should go into deciding
>which FAQ to vote for:
>1) Will JKR even give us an answer?  She's notorious for "Sorry,
>can't tell you" answers.  Though it being in a FAQ means she's more
>likely to give us something.


Surely she wouldn't say, "Here, I'm giving you three questiosn to choose 
from, and whichever gets the most votes will get an answer" and then say 
she can't answer it.  I am sure she'll answer, but if the question is an 
important one, her answer might be tricky.

I voted for #3, because that Howler was worded too oddly to just be a 
reminder of her agreement to take Harry in and protect him.  He could have 
just said, "remember your promise."  And would that have had such an impact 
on her? I think there's definitely more to know there.

Shannon

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]