I'm not proud of it

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 106983

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "ladyramkin2000" :

snip.

>  The Siriophiles and Jacobites can come up with as many 
> excuses as they like.  The behaviour of both these boys (very 
nearly 
> men) is still appalling.  How would you feel if Snape had been YOUR 
> kid?



Alla:

I think I take a grave enough view of how Sirius and James behaved in 
that scene, but I think that begs the comparison question:

How would you feel if  Neville was your child and Snape was his 
teacher?


By the way, I would have been very angry if that was done to my 
child, but afterwards I would have also made sure that my child never 
mutters the word 'mudblood" ever again.