Snape's Patronus
Lissa Hess
drliss at comcast.net
Tue Jul 20 20:58:47 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 107081
>Potioncat:
>At one time I thought (like Chris) that Snape may have learned to be
>an animagus to compete with the Marauders. But Snape doesn't learn
>about Sirius being an animagus until GoF. He certainly didn't
>recognise the Dog. So I don't think we have any canon for his
>being one. We do have a lot of bug-like descriptions of him. (Bat-
>like too.) So I don't know where that leaves us.
>
>As far as the Animagus and Patronus forms being the same. I doubt
>it. The Animagus form seems to be determined by what kind of person
>the wizard is. The Patronus form seems to be determined by what
>sort of Protective-figure (Father/Patron) the wizard has.(or seeks?)
It would be interesting if Snape's patronus was a phoenix, wouldn't it? :)
I am curious as to see what it is- it sounds like we will. (I'd be curious
to see exactly what form Lupin's took too, I certainly can't see a
cockroach chasing down Dementors!)
As far as Snape being an Animagus though, I tend to think not- pretty much
for the same reason I think a Weasley's gonna die- economy of
numbers. Animagi are supposed to be incredibly rare- Hermione said there's
been 7 this century (I assume that's in GB, or GB has a very high
precentage of the worlds' animagi.). We already have 3 unregistered
animagi running around Hogwarts, and Rita Skeeter being an unregistered
animagus. So unless JKR is shooting for thirteen animagi... (I doubt Snape
is a registered animagus because Hermione would have known and mentioned
it, I assume.) How many times can you use the same plot device? I don't
think she'll do that one.
Also, while I think Snape may be redeemed, I get the impression he's never
going to be a nice person. Ever. At least, that's the way she seems to
talk when she says we're all getting a little too fond of Severus!
Lissa
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive