How should Harry deal with Snape

dumbledore11214 dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Wed Jul 28 00:16:14 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 107926

> Pippin:
> 
> Goodness me, no, no,no, Snape is not OK! Snape is damaged.  
> He is so damaged he may never get any better. He has done 
> evil, and I think we will be shocked when we find out how much. 
> So what? Is Harry so perfect that he deserves to inhabit a world 
> of perfect people? I don't think so.



Alla:

Oh, I am glad to read that and sorry for misreading you, but of 
course we will have to disagree on how Harry deserves to be treated 
by a teacher. :)

 
Pippin:
Of course Harry has a right to expect all adults to be 
> more emotionally stable and healthy than he is...or does he? Is 
> that just another prejudice?
> 

Alla:

He has a right to be treated fairly as "Harry" not "James". No, I 
don't think this relates to prejudice in any way, but of course it 
will take half of the fun away from the story.







More information about the HPforGrownups archive