Fudge and Harry as Gryffindor's heir

boyd_smythe boyd.t.smythe at fritolay.com
Thu Jul 29 14:21:02 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 108081

> Kneasy wrote <snip>:
> Harry, now. We may never know what Harry truly is. "What?" you 
cry "how can this be?" Easy. Harry is not solely Harry. There's 
somebody else in there with him - Voldy!Tom. That scar - it's not just 
a transfer of powers, personality was transferred as well. Much has 
been made of Harry 'recognising' Tom - all sorts of theories from 
presentiment right down into the murky depths of time travel. Much 
less has been made of the fact that Tom recognises Harry.
> "So. Your mother  died to  save you. That's a powerful 
counter-charm. I can see now - there is nothing special about you 
after all. I wondered you  see. Because there are strange likenesses 
between us....Probably the only two  Parselmouths to come to Hogwarts 
since the great Slytherin himself. We even look something alike..." 
(CoS)
> What Tom sees is part of himself, transferred along with the 
powers. And Voldy!Tom is probably pure Slytherin fodder, even without 
the possibility that there's some of the original Salazar in Voldy 
too. <

boyd:

Then we're in agreement, Kneasy? Had not Lily's sacrifice embedded 
parts of LV in baby Harry, he might be a mere squib? Let's see, he's a 
strong wizard for his age, just like LV was, he uses the *same* wand 
as LV, he's a parselmouth, and they even look a bit alike. Could it be 
that Squib!Harry got *all* his powers from Voldie?

Boy, if pure-blooded, arrogant James had known baby Harry to be a 
squib, he might have been upset enough to...to...hand Harry over to 
LV to save himself and Lily? See post #107977 (SHH) JAM TAKES BIBS for 
a very subversive theory that could be sadly true.

--boyd





More information about the HPforGrownups archive