Snapes Attitude towards the Students

[Cathy Drolet]

No: HPFGUIDX 108115

stephenflynn001 asked:

> Does anybody know if Snape has every been disciplined for the 
actions 
> and behaviour towards not just Harry but all the students outside 
of 
> Slytherin.  It seems ridiculous that a person with his temperment 
and 
> obvious chip on his shoulder should be responsible for childrens 
> development.



Potioncat:

"Yes, it's in OoP when Umbridge is interviewing him about his 
experience at Hogwarts. Every year he submits his resignation but DD 
refuses to accept it until  he teaches for one full year without 
abuses. Of course he blows that chance with the first Gryffindor 
class."


DuffyPoo:

I think you have a different version of OotP than I have, Potioncat, though that's not necessarily surprising to me, I've seen quite a few discrepancies lately.  I'm assuming your answer to the question is a joke but if not, can you please quote your reference?

I went to school to Snape - well, that wasn't his name but I'm quite sure it was him - he wasn't disciplined for his teaching style then either though that was rather a long time ago.  

We really only see Snape's attitude toward Slytherin and Gryffindor.  Slytherin is his house and it's quite well known that he shows favourtism to them   He may be perfectly normal to Ravenclaw and Hufflepuff kids, though I doubt it.  Why he hasn't been disciplined is anyone's guess; maybe in the WW world they think this kind of treatment by teachers is perfectly normal.

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]