The Prophecy's half fulfilled WAS Re: Neville and the Prophecy

[meidbh]

No: HPFGUIDX 108299

"Cathy Drolet" <cldrolet at s...> wrote:
"So, although you were going off at a slight tangent, Aggie, in my 
theory, Neville can still be the one the prophecy refers to.  But 
no, I guess I don't believe that 'all' of the first half of the 
prophecy has been fulfilled"


Meidbh:
So you're saying that VM has not yet marked his equal?
 
VM certainly marked Harry. Lightning shaped scar. 
  
As for "marking as his equal"- by repelling VMs spell Harry 
demonstrated that he was more than a match for VM. Not only did he 
deflect the spell but he sent it back so fast that VM couldn't dodge 
it. Pretty impressive for an infant. 

I think the concept that VM has yet to mark his equal, although not 
impossible, is a bit too complicated to be likely, especially with 
only two books to go.

And if we assume that VM marked Harry as his equal then it's too 
late for Neville. Harry is the one. Poor Harry. 

Meidbh :-)