Clues to 6&7 in POA film - Don't cry for me Harry Potter

samnanya yswahl at stis.net
Sun Jun 6 22:25:43 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 100200

vmonte
> Regarding the tears scene:
> The scene might have originally been filmed without Harry crying,
> but with him just being upset/mad. The director may have later 
> decided that Harry did not appear as upset as he should have, and
> requested that the crying sounds be added during the film editing.   
> Since Harry was not visible under the cloak, adding crying noises
> is easy. 
> Unfortunately, they should have added tears to his face as well. 
> This type of thing happens all the time.  

samnanya
I would usually agree - sloppy editing is the rule rather than the
exception. THe only reason I am not convinced is that Cuaron and
JKR are both notorious nitpicking perfectionists, and given all
JKR has said about eyes being important, I find it hard to believe
that both of them would let this go......

then again, there was that "K-Mart special" petronus which really
did not sit well with me given that it was the climax of the movie.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive