Aunt Marge Floating (WAS: Re: Harry/James, Crabbe/Goyle connection)

gift_lady clr1971 at alltel.net
Tue Jun 8 15:25:09 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 100407

Potioncat: 
> Sorry, I wasn't very clear. How Marge is shown in the movie is 
> different than the book. And having her floating in the air was very 
> similar in the movie to the Muggle baiting in GoF. The audience 
> found both Marge and Crabbe/Goyle funny...but when similar things 
> happen in the books, they are not funny. 


I did find Aunt Marge funny, mostly because Harry was getting even 
with her for what she was saying to his family. I doubt she'll talk 
about them that way again. I did not think the muggles being 
mistreated in GOF was funny and I hope if it's shown in the movie 
that the audience feels the same. 

Christina in GA (USA)





More information about the HPforGrownups archive