Harry w/Tom (was Question re "little hint" in Bk 2 and Long Lived)
boyd_smythe
boyd.t.smythe at fritolay.com
Fri Jun 11 15:05:39 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 100821
> Caius Marcius wrote:
> "And while Harry was sure he had never heard the name T. M. Riddle
before, it still seemed to mean something to him, almost as though
Riddle was a friend he'd had when he was very small, and had
half-forgotten. But this was absurd. He'd never had friends before
Hogwarts, Dudley had made sure of that."
> Why is Harry's initial reaction to Tom Riddle's name so powerfully
positive? We have not yet been vouchsafed the slightest clue - was
Voldemort in contact with Harry somehow *before* attempting to
murder him? This seems to hint at the mysterious mental link between
Harry and Voldemort that becomes so prominent in OOP. <
Boyd:
Interesting one! There's also a discussion going on right now between
Kneasy and Jo (sorry if I've left someone out here) about whether
Voldemort is some kind of long-lived spirit that possesses its
host--in this case, Tom Riddle. (the Long Lived and Vapour!Mort
threads)
And they've pointed out that during the failed AK of baby Harry, some
of LV may have been somehow deflected into Harry, thus creating the
mental bond we see in OoP.
That train of thought plus yours, Marcius, makes me wonder if....
Suppose Tom were not ESE until possessed by LV in the COS. Perhaps a
castoff due to his background and power, perhaps anti-authority like
many such children from rough-and-tumble homes, and never shown any
love. In a teenage fit of despair/anger, he let in LV, who then
possessed him. But NotESE!Tom.
Fast forward to Godric's Hollow, where Lily's protection wreaks havoc
on PossessedByLV!Tom's AK, causing part of TOM to go into Harry.
So what? Well.... 1. Now LV can't kill Harry without killing his
current/most recent host (Tom), which would be bad for LV if he needs
a host to live through. 2. Now Harry has a part of NotESE!Tom that
has been part of him since he was a child--thus the feeling of
childhood friendship. 3. DD calls LV Tom to remind Tom that he could
defeat LV from within. 4. DD has that gleam in his eye because now
part of Harry is also in LV, and together Tom and Harry could
overthrow LV from within. 5. But to do so, Harry will need to
Legilimens into LV to convince NotESE!Tom that the world (and Tom
himself) are worthy of saving. Thus the focus on
Occlumency/Legilimens in OoP.
Of course, we could then go on to explain how LV will attempt to take
over Harry, and Harry will willingly walk through the veil or
somesuch to sacrifice himself for the good of others in a very
biblical way. But this feels like just one of the many ways JKR could
have this play out.
Boyd
So many possible clues, so little real information.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive