Explosion at GH: but still: Snape once again puts 2 & 2 together...)

brynnleet brynnleet at yahoo.com
Fri Jun 11 22:57:39 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 100975

Susan <teilani2002 at y...> wrote:
> I admit to being very curious about the fact that there was an 
> explosion and the house was destroyed.  Now, even though we 
> don't know anything about what happened at the Longbottoms, I 
> don't recall JKR saying anywhere that AKs (or Imperios) caused 
> explosions, houses to collapse, etc.  Just how did the house get 
> destroyed?
> 
> I am really curious to know who, exactly, was there at GH.  I know 
> this has been brought up before, but I don't recall any satisfying 
> conclusions.  
<snip>


There has been a lot of speculation about who else was at GH 
recently, but what I don't understand in no one could find GH. It 
was under a Secret-Keeper spell, so only someone PP had personally 
told could of been there. PP wouldn't of told any of the "good" guy, 
which seems to mean none of them could of been there, at least while 
the Potter's were alive (does the spell end when they die?). And the 
fact that the DE blamed PP for LV downfall at GH makes me think he 
didn't tell any of them about the location. If he had, they all 
would of known the main reason LV recruited PP was to find the 
Potters, so why would they blame PP for doing what LV wanted? I 
suppose it's possible he told some DE the secret, but it seems 
impossible to Moody or Lupin or teenage!Harry to be at GH before the 
Potter's were killed. 

"brynnleet"





More information about the HPforGrownups archive