Harry's summer in the 6th book

[Steve]

No: HPFGUIDX 101851

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Susan" <teilani2002 at y...> wrote:
>  nadjjaa  wrote:
> 
> > 
> > Sirius can't be really DEAD.  That just makes ZERO sense.
> > 
> > nadjjaa  (HI)

> Hi nadjjaa!
> Just curious, b/c I'm one of the people on this list who really 
> really want him to come back.  So, why does it make zero sense?  ...
> there's been  threads here that propose that his "death" was planned
> ... to help Sirius escape ....  
> 
> However, I'm rather afraid to believe it b/c of JKR's comments that 
> people die, rather suddenly at that, and especially in war.  
> Enlighten me, *please*!
> 
> Susan (Padfot lover ;-)


bboy_mn (now Asian_lovr2):

I agree, Sirius's death makes no sense, but does death ever make
sense? Especially a violent unpredictable death?

If they were going to fake Sirius's death, would they really do it
under such uncontrolled and unpredictable circumstances? Unless the
implication is that Voldemort, Bellatrix, and the DE's were in on the
plot. 

The whole circumstance surrounding Sirius's death is just too
complicated, with WAY TOO MANY variables, and too uncontrollable to
have been an intentional plot for just that purpose. 

Sorry, but I'm just not buying that particular scenerio.

I believe Sirius will come back to the story, but will not come back
to life; dead is dead. 

Steve