Harry's summer in the 6th book

katiegryffindor JOEYPOTTER50 at AOL.COM
Fri Jun 18 11:53:44 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 101873

 
> bboy_mn (now Asian_lovr2):
 
> I agree, Sirius's death makes no sense, but does death ever make
> sense? Especially a violent unpredictable death?
 
> If they were going to fake Sirius's death, would they really do it
> under such uncontrolled and unpredictable circumstances? Unless the
> implication is that Voldemort, Bellatrix, and the DE's were in on 
the plot. 
 
> The whole circumstance surrounding Sirius's death is just too
> complicated, with WAY TOO MANY variables, and too uncontrollable to
> have been an intentional plot for just that purpose. 
 
> Sorry, but I'm just not buying that particular scenerio.
 
> I believe Sirius will come back to the story, but will not come back
> to life; dead is dead. 

Hi new person here :)

I read a Rowling interview where she says that Sirius has to die in 
order for something to happen in book six . She had no choice but to 
kill him . Therefore it must have always been her intention for Harry 
to lose him . I find it a little upsetting that the one parental 
figure he has (apart from Dumbeldore) is taken from him after not too 
long . I also believe that Sirius will come back to the story 
moreover I think he will play an important role . Though sadly I 
think his role will be much like Harrys father - He will be dead yet 
his spirit and legacy will continue . Sirius's death has perhaps 
given Harry the ammunition he needs to fight Voldemort . The anger 
and frustration will no doubt play a main part.

Kate 







More information about the HPforGrownups archive