Time Turner headache

[nkafkafi]

No: HPFGUIDX 102721

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Barbara D. Poland-Waters" <bd-bear at v...> wrote:
> alora wrote:
> 
> If you were just a student or teacher looking into two separate
> classes within a few minutes of each other, and they were two
> classes that Hermione was taking, would you see Hermione in each of
> them?  If she's taking Arithmancy and goes there first, then time
> turns so she can do Divination (I may have the order wrong, I'm just
> doing a "perhaps"), would you be able to peek into both classes and
> see her in each of them?<<<
> 
> Barbara wrote:
> 
> I do get the sense that it works like that, evidenced by Hermione and Ron
> seeing themselves after they did the time-turning thing. I also think the
> faculty (at least the relevant faculty for the classes Hermione was
> registered for) had to know about it. Which does make you wonder, would they
> leave Snape out of the loop, or other teachers whose classes were not in
> conflict on Hermione's schedule?
> 
> Barbara, still hoping for more responses to my post "Some questions/comments
> about OOTP"
> bd-bear

Neri:

To Alora, this is a definite YES to your question. Hermione WAS at two classes at the same 
time.

To Flora, I actually don't see any reason why the teachers (other than McGonagall) should 
have known about it. It does seem that Snape didn't know, and Hermione was also visiting 
Potions while going to other classes. I don't have the book with me but I know there is 
canon for it.

Neri