Snape like teacher

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 103228

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Ashley <sweetongoo at y...> wrote:
snip.
 

> Snape definitely can be compared to McGonagall. She is strict in 
her own womanly way, she can look at a student with those bulging 
eyes and they know what is wrong and what is right. Snape has this 
same look, but since he is a male people get the impression that he 
is some kind of dark and evil person. Women can use this look without 
being questioned because it is our trademark.
 snip.



Alla:


Sorry, not IMO. McGonagall is strict with everybody. Snape is 
arbitrarily unfair. (really don't want to get into my "he is not only 
unfair, but abusive" mood right now) 

Even if you disagree that he is abusive, I really don't see how 
anybody can question Snape's unfairness.

Even though the end of OoP hints that Snape and McGonagall have 
friendly relationship, in my mind Snape has a veeeeeeery long way to 
go before he becomes as good a teacher as Minerva is. :o)