Snape like teacher

[potioncat]

No: HPFGUIDX 103234

x 
> Alla:
> 
> 
> Sorry, not IMO. McGonagall is strict with everybody. Snape is 
> arbitrarily unfair. (really don't want to get into my "he is not 
only 
> unfair, but abusive" mood right now) 
> 
> Even if you disagree that he is abusive, I really don't see how 
> anybody can question Snape's unfairness.
> 
> Even though the end of OoP hints that Snape and McGonagall have 
> friendly relationship, in my mind Snape has a veeeeeeery long way 
to 
> go before he becomes as good a teacher as Minerva is. :o)

Potioncat:
Hi Alla!

Well, Snape is universally strict with everyone and in that I can 
understand his approach.  He is also very unfair to certain students 
which is not right. His teaching method differs a little from his 
discipline method.  

No, I do not think he is as good a teacher as McGonagall.  However, 
I think her treatment of Neville is a little too severe as well.