What shows up in Priori Incantatem? (Was Re: FAQs: Lily died before James?)
Debra
hpsupergeek at yahoo.com
Tue Jun 29 15:37:34 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 103340
> littlegreenpartyhats wrote:
> It still leaves the question
> of why LV's killing curse
> directed at Harry doesn't
> show up in the Priori Incantatem.
I actually brought that discussion up the other day with a few
people. Priori Incantatem supposedly shows, in reverse order, the
spells the wand performed, not the people the wand killed. Why, then,
was there no echo of the intermediate magic VDM performed to get to
various stages on his quest for resurrection? Possibly they weren't
performed with his own wand, but how do you explain the lack of echo
of the Cruciatus and Imperius Curses we saw him perform on Harry in
the graveyard? And the Cruciatus Curses he had undoubtably performed
on Wormtail for disservice, which Harry didn't feel because the
connection was not yet strong enough? And then there's that tried and
true question of why nothing came out of the wand that represented
the failed curse. And then, consequently, what *should* have come out
of the wand? Maybe an echo of the lightning bolt scar?
Some of these, probably the Cruciatus Curses, can be attributed to
the screams of pain the wand issued between some of the echoes. But
what happened to the others?
Debra
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive